Verdict reached in retrial over deadly California wildfire arson case

Loading Video…

This browser does not support the Video element.

Man found guilty in Palisades Fire arson retrial

A Los Angeles jury reached a guilty verdict Friday in the Palisades Fire arson retrial of Jonathan Rinderknecht.

A Los Angeles jury found Jonathan Rinderknecht, a former rideshare driver with dual U.S.-French citizenship, guilty Friday of arson and destruction of property by means of fire in his retrial for sparking the devastating Palisades Fire that left 12 people dead. 

Verdict reached on Friday on retrial

What we know:

In his federal retrial, Rinderknecht faced one count of destruction of property by means of fire and one count of arson affecting property used in interstate commerce. He pleaded not guilty to all charges.

Jonathan Rinderknecht (Credit: Department of Justice)

Jurors had the option to find him guilty on one and not the other. However, after two days of deliberations, they came back guilty on both charges in what was a unanimous decision.

In the retrial, the prosecution focused less on Rinderknecht’s emotions and instead, presented evidence that placed him nearby the scene when the Lachman Fire began.

While Rinderknecht called 911 multiple times to report the fire, prosecutors argued he did that to make himself look good and the move ultimately worked against him.  

Juror speaks out

What they're saying:

A juror spoke to reporters shortly after the verdict, saying he was initially a holdout during deliberations.

"What I will say is that his intent was to start a fire. What that fire did after his actions, whether he can say it or whether no one can say, like who knows, only he will know and only God will know. And so the result of his fire is what ultimately led to Jan. 7," he said.  "I believe everyone should have a fair trial. And I believe everyone, when they go through these trials, they should look at the person, look at case, look at all the evidence, but just remember, at the end of the day, whatever the court decides, whether it be the judge, the jury, or whatever it may be, this is someone's life."

The backstory:

Federal prosecutors allege Rinderknecht set a small fire, dubbed the Lachman Fire, on New Year’s Day 2025 that smoldered underground and reignited six days later to become the deadly Palisades Fire as ferocious Santa Ana winds swept through Southern California.

In addition to killing 12 people, the historic firestorm destroyed thousands of structures and consumed more than 23,000 acres.

Authorities said a short time after the massive fire ignited, Rinderknecht relocated to Florida. He was later tracked down by federal investigators in Melbourne, Florida, where he was arrested and extradited back to California to stand trial.

His first trial ended in a mistrial after a jury deadlocked in June.

The other side:

The defense argued fireworks may have started the original fire instead, saying there wasn’t enough evidence for a conviction.

Rinderknecht's father has also been vocal about how he believes his son has been used as a scapegoat due to the highly emotional nature of the trial. 

What's next:

His sentencing will be scheduled for a later date. 

The Source: Information in this report comes from federal court records, the U.S. Attorney’s Office and previous FOX 11 and FOX News reporting.


 

Crime and Public SafetyCaliforniaNews